Catapult vs trebuchet reddit. In any way the mangonel should be superior over the onager.
Catapult vs trebuchet reddit Catapult vs. The end result is the same in that a heavy object gets hurled through the air, but how the two machines function to reach that end result are different. Despite the historical trebuchet being larger and more complex than a historical catapult, the Trebuchet mech is of high mobility and sustainable firepower for brief engagements. I’m aware that the trebuchet is the superior siege engine, but what made the catapult less useful, and the use of trebuchets becoming more prevelant on the battlefield? A trebuchet is a type of catapult that uses a long arm to throw a projectile. news 0 comments Best Add a Comment Essential Components for Catapult and Trebuchet Teaching I have launched a new engineering course for a STEAM non-profit I am launching and this month we have four classes where we will focus on ancient engineering by building, prototyping, and modifying builds of catapults and trebuchets. Jan 26, 2008 · Here imo the alternatives are 2 Catapults + 2 Macemen or 3 Trebuchets? The first is a lot more robust - even promoted with CR, Macemen and Catapults aren't hopeless in the field. Catapults also have a secondary fire mode to help take down players rather than buildings, if necessary. Plus you can take out the gate on offense easier. Mangonels are basically small tower mounted multi-projectile catapults that are good for decimating armored enemies during a In what scenario. The trebuchet first Here's the thing. I assume it originated from Civilization V where the trebuchet is an upgrade to the catapult. While trebuchets used a sophisticated counterweight system for superior range and power, catapults relied on tension or torsion mechanisms to launch projectiles. I find that catapults are too weak and will be killed by walls in two hits usually. Looking at those legs, all I can think of is stupid sexy Catapult! Seriously though, it's a fun mid-sized support 'Mech that one ups the Trebuchet with jump jets and an additional laser in its basic configuration, and it has a very utilitarian look by BattleTech standards. In and out in no time with a lot of kaputt buildings in between The problem isn't with the argument, it's with the generic term "catapult". I've never met a catapult that could lob a 90kg mass 300 yards. In any way the mangonel should be superior over the onager. I'm not even counting juggernauts. Cannon shoot relatively flat and could hit a vertical wall with full force. While we’re on this, what is the difference between an onager and a catapult? I think historically the onager in aoe2 is used correctly, save for the wheels. There are two main types of trebuchets. If you want to be "specific" like you said, then you shouldn't either. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts The catapults and trebuchets themselves were usually disassembled for transport and built on the spot. Trebuchets are a type of catapult, using gravity (with a counterweight) or traction (people pulling down), to propel the arm and often employing a sling at the end of the arm for greater distance. Doesn't do anything vs building. When the Firestarter gets boring or something. Strength: 12 Range attack: 14 Move: 2 Range: 2 Bonus vs cities +200% (42 range attack vs cities) No defensive terrain bonuses May not melee attack Must use a point of movement to setup Limited visibility Korean Hwach'a Strength: 11 (more fragile) Range attack: 26 No bonus against cities (loses this when upgraded to cannon) Perhaps upvote for Two trebuchet is enough to destroy three corners and still have a little ammo left. I was wondering what is the difference between a mangonnel and a trebuchet. This fire mode lobs gravel over a wider area, dealing less damage but potentially hitting many more enemies. So naturally, I was disappointed when this spell merely tears up the ground. The subreddit made to decide once and for all, which is the superior medieval siege weapon, the trebuchet or the catapult? 148 votes, 13 comments. To siege a castle I’d take a Trebuchet anytime but for open combat on a field against infantry or cavalry the catapult is superior. r/AskReddit is the place to ask and answer thought-provoking questions. Trebuchet What's the Difference? Catapults and trebuchets are both ancient siege weapons that were used to launch projectiles during warfare. Without such a sling, the machine would be a catapult. Giving it elements of control, or situational extra damage, or even utility. If walls are up melee with battering ram is much more effective then catapults. Mar 1, 2022 · Trebuchets make the best memes, unlike the vastly inferior catapult. Jun 22, 2008 · My guess is that Trebuchet units represent "advanced city siege engineering", while the Catapult unit represents the "field engineering" units like Onagers, ballistae, catapults, incendiary pigs etc. You said a "trebuchet is a catapult. I have been thinking about whether to use catapults (know that's not the correct term) or trebuchets, and how the flaming variants of the siege engines are different to the normal variants (especially the difference between flaming and normal ballista, since flaming ballistas don't seem to have splash damage like the oil pots) does anyone know anything about this? Trebuchet actually, it is just more advanced and powerful in pretty much every way. This subreddit is private because of Reddit's inability to provide proper moderation tools and listen… Memes - Memes, including (but not limited to) image macros, demotivational posters, and rage comics are not allowed. Trebuchets are catapults because catapult is an umbrella term. What is the purpose of having catapults 3 and 4 when you can't use them at the same time but they both go basicly the same direction? Why not just have a single catapult there? The trebuchet is for destroying walls not making headshots! Trebuchet operator: Hold my grain Archived post. All trebuchets are catapults but not all catapults are trebuchets y'all arguing over catapult vs trebuchet while I'm over here like 246 20 u/DoomiestTurtle According to Wikipedia, a mangonel uses a counterweight while an onager uses torsion. Here's the thing. The stereotypical catapult is more specifically a mangonel which, of course, falls under catapult as well. Use normal shot if: Your trebuchet crew is inexperienced AND you are trying to hit a small/tightly packed formation Your trebuchet crew is inexperienced and you are trying to fire through a small gap (happens sometimes with the mountains around settlements or if you want to fire through a gap in a wall) You are targeting a non-flammable structure The rest of the time, use flaming shot. Unless it’s your first raid on a fortified castle Onagers are catapults that use torsion to make stone go fast. Catapults can be really deadly in the street to street fighting. Honestly you don't even need the trebuchet to do any damage to the army if you can just use to wipe out some towers and force the enemy into a field battle, giving up their entire defensive advantage. The catapult has a flatter trajectory and a much faster rate of fire. These include traction trebuchets (which are powered entirely by people pulling on one end of the swinging arm) and counterweight trebuchets (which are powered by people pulling down on and releasing a counterweight that swings the arm). Even if the base is out of render range from your trebuchet, you can still hit the base from even a whole square on the map away. Philadelphia 76ers Premier League UFC Business GameStop Moderna Pfizer Johnson & Johnson AstraZeneca Walgreens Best Buy Novavax SpaceX Tesla Crypto If you breached the walls and want to weaken the garrison/militia before charging (they tends to mass behind the breaches), depending on where you can put the siege engine and if the infantry are in plain sight or not, the trebuchet, onagers or ballistas are all viable. The catapult uses tension, the trebuchet uses a counterweight. What was this game called and where could I currently play it? this isn't for siege though we're arguing over the better siege weapon which is clearly a trebuchet all of y'all mofos an your bitch ass catapults and ballistas this message was approved by trebuchet gang Catapults vs Trebuchets: Reddit's War Experiment Funded on Kickstarter wibble. So cannon could do much more effective hits. In terms of the speed and energy of a launched projectile, what is the general difference between a catapult and trebuchet? The history of warfare is marked by the evolution of weapons, each designed to gain an advantage over the enemy. If you're saying "catapult family" you're referring to r/Trebuchet: As seen on TV!Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now Or check it out in the app stores TOPICS Gaming Sports NFL NBA Megan Anderson Atlanta Hawks Los Angeles Lakers Boston Celtics Arsenal F. Having hundreds of pounds of rock above deck on a relatively small wooden boat is probobly a bad idea, not to mention the fact that if it breaks free of the trebuchet, it will probobly crash through the deck, and possibly far enough down to damage the hull. That being said it is the most technologically advanced of the seige engines, so it winning should be no surprise. 28K subscribers in the elderscrollslegends community. Trebuchets use a counterweight to throw stuff and catapults use a spring mechanism. The joke is that the trebuchet is a better siege engine than catapults or ballistae, and people will occasionally get into mock arguments over whether that’s true or not. Edit: Swapped around the juvenile stone throwers because apparently I can't read. There are two main types of trebuchet. It's actually a wiki page on all things trebuchet, catapult, torsion etc. They were often used to launch stones or other heavy objects at a high https://linktr. Explore their designs, mechanics, and historical significance. To me, it seems like the trebuchet would've eventually been used more given its advantages, but I'm still wondering if it completely replaced the catapult, or if the catapult still had its uses. 4 I have been looking at trebuchet designs lately, and I have noticed that most, if not all, have a sling attached to them. I know it's too late, but you could have told these medieval pedants that you were saying you would go get your catapult in order to fight the person who owned the trebuchet in the picture. If you're saying "catapult family" you're referring to Because a trebuchet is both very heavy, and affected more by rough seas than a catapult. Subreddit dedicated to The Elder Scrolls: Legends card game. "A catapult is any device that throws an object, although it commonly refers to the medieval weapon. How do you guy deal with this problem ? We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. EDIT: Wow. This lever, the arm of the catapult, has a basket of some sort on the end that holds the projectile. I am curious how quickly did cannons in the Late Middle Ages and Early Renaissance replaced catapults and trebuchet as siege engines? I am aware that cannons were used since the 14th century but did they render catapults and trebuchet obsolete quickly or was it slow process? Archived post. The onager was an imperial-era Roman torsion powered siege engine. Yes, a trebuchet is a catapult, but a "catapult" is not a trebuchet. At one point, my husband and children wanted to build a trebuchet to deliver our neighbor's dogs' poop back to them. Especially if you have an initiative advantage and can hop about on the jump jets. Dec 22, 2024 · Which better between this two? i mean should you use Trebuchet if you already can build fire onager/mangonel? with high level enggineering skill? When people commonly in meme about Catapult VS Trebuchet, they actually think of Onager Vs Trebuchet. From there it spread (along with the Deus Vult meme) to reddit. So while the catapult could do very little damage to the trebuchet, it doesn't need to destroy it, or even damage it at all. Mangonel and onager are two types of catapults that were used in different parts of the world. Throw a general behind for morale and those fire shots will wipe the streets while your spears hold the line. This is probably going to get massively downvoted, but for what it's worth, I decided to do some investigation into the actual question asked by the OP about which of the catapult and trebuchet is better. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Can destroy wall. Trebuchet, siege engine utilizing a long arm and the principles of leverage to launch projectiles. They're not the same thing. If you're the catapult, you gotta stay close, inside their min range, and keep moving after every shot. Catapults are typically smaller and simpler in design, using tension or torsion to propel the projectile. Catapult Vs Trebuchet is irony because it would be non-specified catapult vs Trebuchet-type-catapult. What advantage would field cannons have against, say, trebuchets/catapults/other siege engines on the battlefield? Field cannons predating explosive shot. As you We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. It's not game breaking by any metric, but it's easily the most annoying mechanics in the game, in my opinion. Seriously, whoever thought it was a good idea to give mangonels basically the same range as tower ballistas and trebuchets was either stupid, or an asshole. It first appeared in China by the 4th century BC. Catapult can launch the chads and we can shoot crates of monster into area 51 with the trebuchet There's two, right? Trebuchet is the most OP unit in the game. Answer: It is a longstanding joke on reddit to talk about the differences, and to gang up on people who use the word catapult as a catch all term for big flingy thing. 42M subscribers in the AskReddit community. A catapult uses tension or torsion mechanisms like twisted ropes or a flexed arm to launch projectiles. The website has not been updated since 2010 but all of the links I clicked on took me where they were made to. index config About Community The fun part of the Catapult spell is the fact you can throw any small object around the battlefield. Have a few units of spearmen block the street with a catapult right behind them (the closer to the front, the less likely friendly fire will happen). I know that artillery outranks any ranged unit, but I'm wondering about cannon, trebuchet, catapult, and also how they compare to comp bows, and crossbows. All trebuchets are catapults, but not all catapults are trebuchets. ee/recoil_mojoGames I play and stream on PC: Mount and Blade II: Bannerlord Mods / WoW: The Burning Crusade Classic (TBCC) / Overwatch / Half- When times are tough and there is nothing but dark roads in your path, open up the light of trebuchet memes into your heart. However, there are some key differences between the two. The Romans could build miles of palisade walls or huge bridges in days using local materials. Trebuchet: Everything You Need To Know About The Difference Between Catapult And Trebuchet What is the difference between a catapult and a trebuchet? Uncover the distinctions between these ancient siege weapons in this informative article. Hi, I have noticed that trebuchets are very inaccurate while catapults are highly accurate but they kill only 1 or 2 per shot Which is the best artillery unit to use in case of a) seige battles B) open battles Thanks Countering catapults/onagers? How? The opponent shows up with 15+ of them (along with the rest of his troops) and plows through my armies even though they're much larger In the right hands, trebuchets were even accurate enough to provide counter-fire against other siege weapons, as was the case during the siege of Mortagne in 1340, where a small trebuchet built by the defenders was able to destroy a larger besieging trebuchet after only three well-placed shots. It's better than the catapult spell because trebuchets are superior seige weapons to catapults, hence why the spell is overpowered. No one's arguing that. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. What is the diferent between a catapult and a trebuchet? Trebuchets are a type of catapult. The main differences lie in their design and functionality. That's Colossal Thunder in the background, the world record holding trebuchet. When going for aggressive war archers and melee units can take a city much quicker. So on your 2nd, 3rd, or even 4th destroyed trebuchet you'll finally get 2 out at once and then they should destroy the defender's catapults or ballistas (I've never seen them build trebuchets) and once those are destroyed you can easily assault the walls with a ram or siege tower or even just ladders with relative ease, OR you can destroy the Sometimes they start out as first or second, but end up being the third anyways. Catapults (more correctly called onagers) use the torsion of twisted rope to whip a lever forward with great speed. I was okay with helping, but then it evolved to first flaming dog poop and then to flinging the children around. Virgin vs. The design of a trebuchet allows it to launch projectiles of greater weights and further distances than a traditional catapult. Mangonels are basically small tower mounted multi-projectile catapults that are good for decimating armored enemies during a The Hero Trebuchet. Use r/MinecraftMemes to post memes. Share a bit about using these units compared to catapults when taking cities. “Real” trebuchet or not, neat project! Trebuchet and catapults hurled stones in arcs, so when they came down they glanced off walls. How do you use catapult, trebuchet and bombard for siege ? From ancient to renaissance these artilerry only have range of 2 and AI city with wall usually shoot them first than my infantry. How much damage does the trebuchet do? : r/ConanExiles r/ConanExiles Current search is within r/ConanExiles Remove r/ConanExiles filter and expand search to all of Reddit 28M subscribers in the Showerthoughts community. Sep 2, 2021 · Don't get thrown aside—learn the specific difference between trebuchets and catapults so you'll be ready for your next medieval reenactment. The trebuchet tends to be more powerful, but also more cumbersome to transport and install. Essentially, the little annoying brother to the Catapult and Longbow. The Home of For Honor on Reddit! For Honor is a Third-Person Fighting Game, developed and published by Ubisoft for Windows PC, Xbox One/Series X and PlayStation 4/5. The mangonel is more of a kind of a trebuchet. Picking up some rocks and chipping the corners off to fit the catapult would be child's play to them. So an onager and a catapult are the same thing at different sizes, while a mangonel and a trebuchet are the same thing at different sizes. crumpling vs folding toilet paper. In round two the catapult's greater mobility means that it could be pushed across the field to ram into the trebuchet. For those that prefer composites/crossbows until artillery shows up. r/Trebuchet: As seen on TV!Below is a list of pages in this wiki visible to you in this subreddit. Is there a way to adjust distance when firing catapults? The ones used on top of towers just shoot wayyyy past enemy spawn in multiplayer so they are basically useless. " Is it in the same family? Yes. As someone who is a scientist who studies catapults, I am telling you, specifically, in science, no one calls trebuchets catapults. Things like Caltrops, Oil, Acid, and even bags of flour, can be used to spice up the spell. When cannon started being used fortress walls were built thicker. In fact, they are the French version of a catapult! The type of catapult that most people are familiar with is actually called a Mangonel catapult. I know some castles had Trebuchet or Catapult for protection. 176K subscribers in the virginvschad community. This essay will delve into the intricacies of these two siege weapons, comparing Catapult vs. It revolves around physics and motion laws, instead of tension and Treb: Good vs troops but becomes great after they had a few exp rank. A mangonel, also called the traction trebuchet, was a type of siege engine used in China starting from the Warring States period, and later across Eurasia in the 6th century AD. A catapult typically uses tension or torsion to . Catapult vs Trebuchet - AV would know which is the superior siege engine so this had to be a choice based on acceleration and angle for a human projectile, right? r/Trebuchet Current search is within r/Trebuchet Remove r/Trebuchet filter and expand search to all of Reddit What is your opinion on: Catapult, Trebuchet, Siege Tower, Battering Ram, Laddermen For attacking enemy castles in your opinion? A trebuchet looks cool - but you actually won't get that much extra range for the added complexity. Sure, it doesn't have a lot of ammo, but it has enough armour and heat sinks to do decently in a brawl with its medium lasers. Sep 2, 2021 · A trebuchet is a specific version of the catapult that uses a counterweight to create the force to fling an object from a sling at the end of a pole. Any truth to this story? During his war against the Aztecs, Cortez supposedly built a trebuchet to save on gunpowder. Jan 4, 2024 · Catapults and trebuchets are both medieval siege engines, but they operate differently. Jun 7, 2024 · Before the advent of gunpowder, enemy combatants used a powerful siege weapon called a trebuchet to forcefully launch projectiles - sometimes a large stone, a decapitated human head or a dead horse - at intended targets. com “Both trebuchets and catapults were formidable machines that revolutionized medieval warfare. These are some of our favorites. The first is the traction trebuchet, or mangonel, which uses manpower to swing the arm. Because for me the design is more or less the same and they both use a counterweight. Trebuchet has the best accuracy. Among the most fascinating are siege weapons, specifically the catapult and the trebuchet. I find trebuchet too unwieldy to use, and ballista kills too slowly ( making kebabs are fun though). Spread makes it inconsistent but you are not risking troops pushing the ram. Feb 8, 2025 · What was the most amount trebuchet or catapults to use in a single battle, how many could a country actually use, and what prevented them from being implemented? See full list on knowyourmeme. A subreddit for sharing those miniature epiphanies you have that highlight the oddities within the… How to build Siege Equipment including Trebuchets in Knights of Honor 2: Sovereign! Mar 12, 2025 · A catapult and a trebuchet are both types of siege weapons used in ancient warfare. It was a common powerful siege engine until the advent of gunpowder. What is the best way to take city in civ 6? Why use catapults instead of siege towers? What is the difference between towers and battering rams? Thanks! Nov 17, 2016 · The other important thing to know about members of the trebuchet fandom is that they hate catapults, an inferior siege that’s used by fools. r/Trebuchet: As seen on TV!Press J to jump to the feed. My question is was there only 1 trebuchet or catapult and it could have been aimed in any direction and side at war? or it was unmovable and there was one trebuchet or catapult in every direction? There was a flash game I played back in high school 2014-2018 that was based around beating different situations with a catapult or trebuchet. Some guys put tremendous tension on some sort of string or rope and release that tension so the stone flies of. Human should be able to beat the AI here regardless of which side to take. The trebuchet was one of the top choices for artillery in ancient and medieval warfare, having the ability to throw heavier projectiles farther than earlier catapults could. Horsemen are ok but once walls are up are useless against cities, while melee Catapult vs Trebuchet When comparing catapults and trebuchets, both are ancient siege weapons used for hurling projectiles, yet they operate on distinct principles. Reply juggilinjnuggala • Additional comment actions In what scenario. If you're the trebuchets, move everone back a bit, wait for the catapult to choose a target, and then have everyone use the "attack ground" command near the catapult. These two machines, while similar in purpose, differ significantly in design, operation, and effectiveness. Jan 18, 2024 · Which one is cooler, better, or faster, preferred between you guys? I recently got both Da Vinci models from Hobby Lobby and am interested and how vastly different they are. Tips: don't use them to destroy tower, fire archer do that, treb are a weapon for wall and infantry. Eventually r/trebuchetmemes was born. I haven't read through your link to see if they say this, but placing the mangonel on wheels is one way to increase range fairly dramatically. C. A trebuchet is a type of catapult. I prefer the trebuchet, as I think it's a better idea. Thanks OP! Catapult has always been my favourite mech. Mangonels are operated by lots of guys pulling on strings and their combined strength and/or bodyweight makes the stone go via a lever. In contrast, a trebuchet relies on a counterweight to swing an arm and launch its payload. I've never seen that thing used effectively. " -Googled catapult vs trebuchet 3) Trebuchet are siege weapons that use a swinging arm to throw a projectile. There are different mechanism designs for both but that's the main difference. If literally your only goal is to pressure a castle, a trebuchet is usually the best option, for the reason you state. Crossbow: Great vs troops right off the bat, also seems to be abit better vs cav and elephant. They also fulfil their roles just fine - in a suicide charge Catapults deal twice as much collateral per hammer as Trebuchets. Chad and its expanded universe. Reply Thund3rPr0 14NB • Additional comment actions Besides, siege tower advances slowly so you have plenty of times to stone your enemies to unconsciousness. Apr 23, 2024 · Trebuchet A trebuchet (French: trébuchet) is a type of catapult that uses a long arm to throw a projectile. Although they both share the same purpose of launching projectiles over long distances, there are distinct differences between them. I have read at some people prefer composites over the catapult/trebuchet, even though the latter has 200% bonus versus cities. This reminds me of my much younger days making all sorts of catapult and trebuchet devices with popsicle sticks, rubber bands and hot glue. The higher you build the trebuchet tower, the farther the boulders will go. I have video of it too, I'll post. I still feel catapult pulls ahead of ballista on offense and defense because there is normally at least one sweet spot among placement where the volume of kills is superior. 2M subscribers in the oddlyspecific community. Catapult is the parent term for all catapults. The ballista is ok, but I hardly find extra slots in my army for using it. I never tried to take a city without siege unit. that were used from ancient times to gunpowder. They name a few trebuchet simulators on their wiki and the one I tried was very detailed and asked for measurements and mass, projectile mass and so on. The trebuchet is an improved iteration of the mangonel. On the first shot, the projectile went straight up, came straight back down and destroyed it. Archived post. Trebuchet are the superior siege engine, but this guy is still a beast. If there's no walls up the archers can make quick work of the city. For all your Raid needs. They could damage them but the physics was against them. In this blog post, we will delve into the specifics of each of these ancient weapons, their origins, their strengths and weaknesses, and how they were used in warfare throughout history. Overall, trebuchet is a better multi purpose tool. But other units offer their own benefits that can make them better in other situations: -Siege Rams have much greater combat utility than trebuchets. ltdy pxmej gsyf emeevyl supyfnmf vqrco muu oujvjgn cntfbofu dsczi sfou xnwj kgqsrt nnfaxle jnyyau